Choosing the right budget-friendly MPV in India can be tough.
If you’re stuck in a Maruti Ertiga vs Toyota Rumion vs Maruti XL6 comparison, understanding their similarities and differences is key.
I’ve researched these popular models to uncover which might be the perfect fit for your family’s needs.
Key Takeaways
- The Maruti Ertiga, Maruti XL6, and Toyota Rumion are popular choices for budget-friendly and spacious MPVs in India.
- All three cars offer very similar core specifications like engine and fuel efficiency.
- Choosing the best car for you will depend on factors like price sensitivity, brand preference, and desired features.
For the absolute lowest price and best fuel economy (especially CNG), the Maruti Ertiga wins. If the Toyota badge and resale value matter most, consider the Rumion. If you want maximum comfort and a touch of style, the Maruti XL6 is worth the extra cost.
Maruti Ertiga vs Toyota Rumion vs Maruti XL6: Overview
Let’s start with a brief introduction to each of these popular MPVs:
- Maruti Suzuki Ertiga: A long-standing favorite renowned for its practicality, value-for-money proposition, and fuel efficiency.
- Toyota Rumion: Essentially a rebadged version of the Ertiga, but with the added cachet of the Toyota brand, and the potential for slightly higher resale value.
- Maruti Suzuki XL6: A slightly more premium and stylish take on the Ertiga, featuring captain seats in the second row and sportier design cues for some variants.
Importantly, all three MPVs are targeted at similar audiences – families who put space, comfort, and budget-friendliness as top priorities.
Hyundai Creta vs Maruti Suzuki Grand Vitara
Engine and Performance
Under the hood, the Maruti Ertiga, Toyota Rumion, and Maruti XL6 share largely identical powertrains. This results in a very even playing field when it comes to performance and fuel efficiency.
| Specification | Maruti Ertiga | Toyota Rumion | Maruti XL6 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Engine Displacement (cc) | 1462 | 1462 | 1462 |
| Fuel Type | Petrol/CNG | Petrol/CNG | Petrol |
| Transmission | Manual, Automatic | Manual, Automatic | Manual, Automatic |
| Power (bhp) | 103 | 103 | 103 |
| Torque (Nm) | 138 | 138 | 138 |
| Mileage (ARAI Certified kmpl) | 20.51 (Petrol), 26.11 (CNG) | 20.51 (Petrol), 26.11 (CNG) | 20.97 (MT), 20.27 (AT) |
- Understanding the Specifications: All three cars have 1.5-liter petrol engines. Maruti offers them with fuel-efficient CNG options. Transmissions include both manual and automatic choices. Power and torque figures are the same across the board.
- Real-World Performance: These MPVs offer adequate performance for daily usage within cities and highways. Don’t expect lightning-fast acceleration, but they handle everyday commutes and family road trips comfortably.
- Fuel Efficiency Advantage: Both the Ertiga and Rumion boast impressive, class-leading fuel economy, especially noticeable if choosing the CNG variants.
Exterior Design and Dimensions
While visually similar, there are subtle differences in the appearance of the Maruti Ertiga, Toyota Rumion, and Maruti XL6 that give each its own personality. Size-wise, all three are very similar, so interior room should be close.
| Specification | Maruti Ertiga | Toyota Rumion | Maruti XL6 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Length (mm) | 4395 | 4395 | 4445 |
| Width (mm) | 1735 | 1735 | 1755 |
| Height (mm) | 1690 | 1690 | 1700 |
| Wheelbase (mm) | 2740 | 2740 | 2740 |
| Ground Clearance (mm) | 180 | 180 | 180 |
Design Differences
- Maruti Suzuki Ertiga: Features a classic and functional MPV design. Recent updates incorporate a new chrome grille and redesigned taillights for a touch of style.
- Toyota Rumion: With its Toyota badge and subtle aesthetic tweaks, it presents a slightly more refined look compared to the Ertiga.
- Maruti Suzuki XL6: Exudes a bolder and more SUV-like presence with its black cladding, roof rails, and a more sculpted front end. This is especially true in the higher-end ‘Alpha’ variants.
The Importance of Dimensions
Dimensions like length, width, and height directly impact both the outward appearance of a car and its interior space. With nearly identical measurements, all three cars should offer a very similar amount of room for passengers. The identical ground clearance means each should be equally capable of handling typical Indian road conditions.
Interior Features and Comfort
MPVs thrive on interior spaciousness and thoughtful features that make journeys comfortable. Let’s dive into how the Ertiga, Rumion, and XL6 perform in this respect:
Seating and Space
- All three models offer three-row, 7-seater configurations.
- Maruti Ertiga & Toyota Rumion: Bench seating in the second row caters to carrying the most passengers when needed. Both cars offer good legroom and shoulder room even in the third row, suitable for shorter journeys or smaller adults and children.
- Maruti XL6: Stands apart with its second-row captain seats offered in higher variants, giving a more luxurious and spacious feel.
Comfort-Oriented Amenities
- Air Conditioning: As standard, all three come with powerful AC systems essential for India’s climate, with rear AC vents for good airflow to all rows.
- Adjustable Seating: Adjustable seats and steering wheels help customize a comfortable driving position.
- Storage Spaces: Plenty of cup holders, door pockets, and a decent-sized boot (especially with the third-row seats folded down) make them all very practical for daily life and longer trips.
- Technology: Touchscreen infotainment systems with various connectivity features (Android Auto, Apple CarPlay) may vary slightly between models and trim levels.
Safety Features
Safety should never be compromised when choosing a family car. Fortunately, Maruti Suzuki and Toyota take this seriously with features across the Ertiga, Rumion, and XL6 range.
| Specification | Maruti Ertiga | Toyota Rumion | Maruti XL6 |
|---|---|---|---|
| ABS (Anti-Lock Braking System) | Standard | Standard | Standard |
| EBD (Electronic Brakeforce Distribution) | Standard | Standard | Standard |
| Airbags (No.) | 2-4, variant-wise | 2-4, variant-wise | 2-6, variant-wise |
| Hill Hold Control | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Electronic Stability Program | Yes | Yes | Yes |
- Essential Protections: Basic safety standards like ABS, EBD, and dual front airbags are in place across all three.
- Higher-Trim Options: Opting for more feature-rich variants unlocks additional airbags (side and curtain), along with safety tech like Hill Hold Control and Electronic Stability Program, boosting protection further.
Toyota Corolla Cross Facelift Launch Date In India & Price
Driving Experience and Handling
Beyond specifications, how these MPVs feel on the road matters to both drivers and passengers.
While fundamentally similar, there are some nuances between how the Ertiga, Rumion, and XL6 handle:
- City Maneuvers: Due to their reasonable dimensions and power steering, all three models navigate crowded city streets fairly easily. Parking sensors become a welcome assist.
- Highway Stability: At higher highway speeds, these MPVs feel adequately stable but won’t win any sports car awards. Some body roll (sway) can be expected around corners.
- Riding Over Rough Patches: Suspension tuning favors comfort. They cope well with most bumps and broken roads typically encountered in India.
- XL6 Distinction: Some reviewers note the XL6 feels slightly sportier in its handling. This could be due to minor suspension tweaks or its different visual stance.
| Characteristic | Maruti Ertiga | Toyota Rumion | Maruti XL6 |
|---|---|---|---|
| City Driving | Manageable size, light steering for navigating traffic | Same as Ertiga | Slightly wider stance might feel less nimble compared to the Ertiga |
| Highway Cruising | Feels adequately stable for its class | Same as Ertiga | May exhibit slightly more confidence at higher speeds due to a slightly lower center of gravity |
| Steering Feedback | Light, easy to maneuver, may provide less road feel | Same as Ertiga | Could feel slightly more responsive or communicative compared to the Ertiga |
| Suspension | Tuned for comfort, handles most bumps and imperfections well | Same as Ertiga | May feel a touch firmer than the Ertiga depending on tire selections |
| Overall Feel | Practical and dependable for everyday errands | Same as Ertiga | Might give a marginally more engaging experience for enthusiast drivers |
Ownership Costs
When buying a car, upfront costs are important, but long-term expenses must also be considered. The Maruti Ertiga, Toyota Rumion, and Maruti XL6 are seen as affordable by those searching in this segment.
| Specification | Maruti Ertiga | Toyota Rumion | Maruti XL6 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Starting Ex-showroom Price | ₹8.69 Lakh | ₹10.44 Lakh | ₹11.61 Lakh |
| Maintenance Costs | Generally Low | Generally Low | Generally Low |
| Spare Parts Availability | Easily Available | Easily Available | Easily Available |
| Resale Value | Good | Good | Good |
- Price Differences: The Maruti Ertiga starts out as the most affordable option in the comparison. With comparable specs, the Toyota Rumion commands a premium largely due to the Toyota brand value. The Maruti XL6 has the highest starting price, due partly to its more premium features.
- Service and Spares: Maruti Suzuki boasts an extensive service network and spare parts availability across India, giving reassurance to owners of the Ertiga and XL6. Toyota generally also enjoys similar good serviceability.
- Resale Value: Maruti cars are known for holding their value reasonably well in the used car market. Toyota’s strong brand also plays a role in the Rumion likely maintaining good resale prices.
Maruti Ertiga vs Toyota Rumion vs Maruti XL6: Pros and Cons
To summarize the advantages and potential drawbacks of each car, here’s a quick breakdown:
Maruti Ertiga
- Pros: Most budget-friendly option, superb fuel efficiency with petrol/CNG choices, proven reliability.
- Cons: Less premium feeling compared to XL6, Toyota badge lacks desirability for some.
Toyota Rumion
- Pros: Benefits from Toyota’s reputation for quality and potentially higher resale, the same practicality as the Ertiga.
- Cons: Priciest option among the three, not much to differentiate it from the Ertiga besides the badge.
Maruti XL6
- Pros: Offers plusher captain seats option, bolder design sets it apart, overall slightly more upmarket feel than the Ertiga.
- Cons: Carries the highest price tag of the group, loses potential third-row passenger capacity with captain seats.
Maruti Ertiga vs Toyota Rumion vs Maruti XL6 Comparison: Verdict
Choosing the ultimate ‘winner’ among these MPVs becomes a matter of personal priorities and what fits your budget. Here’s a simplified guidance:
- Value Seeker: If low pricing and the potential of maximum fuel savings with a CNG option are of top importance, the Maruti Ertiga makes the most sense.
- Toyota Loyalist: If the Toyota badge carries significant weight with you and resale value is critical, the Toyota Rumion is suitable despite costing more.
- Comfort and Style Conscious: If captain seats and a slightly more ‘premium’ ownership experience are desired, consider stretching your budget for the Maruti XL6.
Sure, here’s the FAQs section to complete your informative article:
Frequently Asked Questions
Which car offers the best mileage?
The Maruti Ertiga and Toyota Rumion offer the best mileage in this comparison, with an ARAI certified mileage of 20.51 kmpl for the petrol variant and 26.11 kmpl for the CNG variant. The Maruti XL6 has a slightly lower mileage due to its heavier weight and different tire configuration.
Is the Toyota Rumion worth the extra cost over the Maruti Ertiga?
The Toyota Rumion is essentially a rebadged version of the Maruti Ertiga with a few minor cosmetic changes. It is priced slightly higher than the Ertiga due to the Toyota brand name. Whether the extra cost is worth it depends on how much value you place on the Toyota badge and the slightly better fit and finish of the Rumion.
Are there any upcoming updates or facelifts for these models?
There are no confirmed updates or facelifts for these models as of February 2024. However, it is possible that Maruti Suzuki and Toyota may introduce minor updates or facelifts in the near future to keep these models competitive in the market.
Are there automatic transmission options?
Yes, all three models are available with automatic transmission options. The Maruti Ertiga and Toyota Rumion offer a 4-speed torque converter automatic transmission, while the Maruti XL6 offers a 6-speed torque converter automatic transmission.
Which car is the safest?
All three models offer a similar level of safety features, including ABS, EBD, dual airbags, and ISOFIX child seat mounts. The Maruti XL6 offers a few additional safety features, such as hill hold control and electronic stability control.
Is there anything else I should consider when choosing between these cars?
In addition to the factors mentioned above, you should also consider your personal preferences, such as the size and layout of the car, the features that are important to you, and your budget. It is also a good idea to test drive all three cars before making a decision.
2 thoughts on “Maruti Ertiga vs Toyota Rumion vs Maruti XL6 comparison: Unbiased MPV Comparison”