Mahindra XUV400 vs Tata Nexon EV comparison: Budget EV Face-Off

Mahindra XUV400 vs Tata Nexon EV comparison: These popular electric SUVs are transforming the Indian market. But which one should you choose?

I’ve done the research to break down everything from price and features to performance and real-world practicality.

Key Takeaways

• XUV400 offers a larger size and slightly more range.
• Nexon EV often has a price advantage with its various models.
• Features may vary across trim levels – research what’s included carefully.
• Consider your primary driving needs (space, performance, charging access) to make the best decision.

Mahindra XUV400 vs Tata Nexon EV Comparison: Verdict

The Mahindra XUV400 offers more space and potentially better range.

The Nexon EV typically has a price advantage and excels in value-for-money.

For city driving, both are excellent. Ultimately, the best EV for you depends on your budget and whether you prioritize size and range or cost-effectiveness.

Price and Variants

Let’s start with the crucial question of cost. Here’s a breakdown of variant-wise pricing for both models:

Model	Ex-Showroom Price (INR)
Mahindra XUV400 EC	₹15.99 lakhs – ₹17.49 lakhs
Mahindra XUV400 EL	₹18.99 lakhs
Tata Nexon EV Prime	₹14.49 lakhs – ₹16.99 lakhs
Tata Nexon EV Max	₹16.49 lakhs – ₹18.99 lakhs

Important Note: EV prices might fluctuate slightly based on location and state-specific subsidies.

Dimensions and Exterior Design

When it comes to presence, the XUV400 holds a slight edge in size. Here’s how the measurements compare:

Specification	Mahindra XUV400	Tata Nexon EV
Length	4200 mm	3993 mm
Width	1821 mm	1811 mm
Height	1634 mm	1617 mm
Wheelbase	2600 mm	2498 mm
Ground Clearance	205 mm	205 mm
Boot Space	378 L / 418 L	350 L

In terms of design, both cars offer contrasting aesthetics.

The XUV400 has a more SUV-like stance with its longer dimensions and muscular design cues.

The Nexon EV embraces a sportier crossover image with sharper lines and a slightly raised profile. The ultimate choice hinges on your personal style preference.

Interior Features and Comfort

Stepping inside, you’ll find both EVs offer decently equipped cabins. Let’s break down the key features:

Feature	Mahindra XUV400	Tata Nexon EV
Seating	5	5
Upholstery	Leatherette	Fabric/Leatherette
Sunroof	Optional	Optional
Infotainment System	7-inch touchscreen	7-inch touchscreen
Connected Car Technology	Yes	Yes
Automatic Climate Control	Yes	Yes

Cabin space is adequate in both cars, but the XUV400’s longer wheelbase might translate to slightly better rear legroom.

It’s best to experience both models in person to gauge actual comfort levels.

Performance & Driving Dynamics

Let’s see how these two electric SUVs stack up on the road:

Specification	Mahindra XUV400	Tata Nexon EV Prime	Tata Nexon EV Max
Motor Power	110 kW (150 hp)	95 kW (129 hp)	105 kW (143 hp)
Torque	310 Nm	245 Nm	250 Nm
Battery Capacity	34.5 kWh / 39.4 kWh	30.2 kWh	40.5 kWh
Acceleration (0-100 kmph)	8.3 sec / 8.6 sec	9.9 sec	9 sec
Top Speed	150 kmph	120 kmph	137 kmph

While both electric SUVs offer the instant acceleration and silent operation typical of EVs, there are differences in how they deliver their power and feel on the road.

• Power & Acceleration: The XUV400 boasts a significantly more powerful electric motor, especially in its top-end EL variant. This translates to a thrilling 0-100 kmph sprint in about 8.3 seconds for the EC version and 8.6 seconds for the EL. While not slow, the Nexon EV Prime and Max take closer to 9 and 9.9 seconds, respectively. This could impact overtaking maneuvers on the highway or the overall zippiness while accelerating from a standstill.
• Steering and Handling: Both cars are tuned for easy city driving. Their steering is light, aiding maneuverability in congested areas. However, neither is an enthusiast’s dream – feedback through the steering wheel may be minimal, and there could be some body roll during spirited cornering.
• Ride Comfort: The suspension setup will slightly favor comfort over outright sportiness in both cars. City roads and well-maintained highways will be tackled confidently. However, rough roads could filter through some vibrations. It’s best to test drive both EVs to assess your personal preference in this regard.
• Regenerative Braking: Both EVs feature regenerative braking that lets you recoup energy while slowing down. Some EVs offer adjustable levels of regeneration, impacting driving feel. If possible, during test drives, check if the braking feel in each EV fits your driving style. Stronger regeneration can lead to almost “one-pedal” driving in the city.

Battery, Range, and Charging

The heart of an EV lies in its battery and driving range. Here’s how the XUV400 and Tata Nexon EV compare:

Specification	Mahindra XUV400 EC	Mahindra XUV400 EL	Tata Nexon EV Prime	Tata Nexon EV Max
Battery Capacity	34.5 kWh	39.4 kWh	30.2 kWh	40.5 kWh
ARAI Claimed Range	375 km	456 km	312 km	437 km
Real-World Range (Approx.)	250-300 km	300-350 km	200-250 km	300-350 km

Charging Options

• DC Fast Charging: Both the XUV400 and Nexon EV support DC fast charging, potentially taking them from 0-80% in under an hour with a compatible charger.
• AC Home Charging: Using a standard AC charger (e.g., a 7.2 kW wall box), charging times increase significantly – expect a full charge overnight.

Important Note:

• Driving style, ambient temperature, and use of features like AC can impact real-world range.
• Availability of DC fast-charging infrastructure in your area will influence charging convenience.

Safety Features

Safety should never be compromised. Let’s see how the XUV400 and Tata Nexon EV ensure occupants’ well-being:

Safety Feature	Mahindra XUV400	Tata Nexon EV
Airbags	6	2
ABS with EBD	Yes	Yes
ESC	Yes	Yes
Traction Control	Yes	Yes
Hill Hold / Hill Descent Control	Yes	Yes
ISOFIX child seat mounts	Yes	Yes

Please note: Not all safety features might be available across all variants.

At present, neither model has undergone Global NCAP crash tests. It’s worth checking if these ratings become available later, as they are a good indicator of crashworthiness.

Cost of Ownership & Warranty

Owning an EV involves factors beyond the initial purchase price. Here’s a peek into ownership costs:

• Maintenance: EVs generally require less frequent maintenance than conventional vehicles due to fewer moving parts.
• Battery Health: EV batteries gradually degrade over time, potentially impacting range.
• Warranty: Both Mahindra and Tata offer extensive warranties on their batteries and the overall vehicle. Check manufacturer websites for exact terms and conditions.

Pros and Cons

Finally, a quick summary of the strengths and weaknesses of each EV:

Mahindra XUV400

• Pros
  • Larger size, increased cabin and boot space
  • Potential for slightly better real-world range
  • Powerful acceleration
• Cons
  • May be higher priced than comparable Nexon EV variants
  • Slightly less feature-rich inside (depending on the variant)

Tata Nexon EV

• Pros
  • Multiple variants at different price points for cost-conscious buyers
  • Typically good feature availability across most trims
  • Proven record in the EV market
• Cons
  • Smaller than the XUV400
  • Real-world range may be a bit less than the XUV400

FAQs

Conclusion

The Mahindra XUV400 and Tata Nexon EV are both strong choices in India’s growing market for affordable electric SUVs.

The XUV400 offers superior size and potential for slightly longer range, while the Nexon EV benefits from multiple variants across different price points and a proven track record.